Clinical Threshold

Posted on Fri Mar 27th, 2026 @ 8:18am by Lieutenant JG Rowan Hale
Edited on on Fri Mar 27th, 2026 @ 6:03pm

1,017 words; about a 5 minute read

Mission: Character Development
Location: Sickbay
Timeline: Current

It had been a quiet shift.

Sickbay was mostly empty; the usual rhythm pared back to routine checks and low priority cases. Commander House had been released under monitor and observe status, with follow-up tests scheduled as required.

Rowan stood for a moment, with nothing needing him immediately.

From the office partition, he watched the floor. Two medics stood near a console, speaking in low tones. The conversation itself wasn't unusual, but the way it shifted.. Paused, then picked up again was. One of them glanced towards the office door. Then the other. It was subtle, easy to miss if you weren't looking for it.

Rowan stepped out to the main Sickbay. The two officers straightened slightly, exchanged a brief look, then moved off in different directions, each finding something else to occupy their attention. It wasn't the first time. Conversations had a way of ending when he entered a room. Glances were cut short. Voices lowered.

It had started after Batel.

He'd let It go the first few times, expecting it would settle on its own, but it hadn't, so he called them in.

It wasn't formal. No summons, no urgency. Just a quiet request that those on duty gather near the central console. They came gradually, finishing what they were doing first. Some were curious, some already aware why.

Rowan stood with his hands loosely behind his back. "There have been questions," he said, his attention moving across the group, "regarding recent clinical decisions."

"Sir.." One of the junior officers spoke up hesitantly.

"Ensign?"

"Some of us have been talking." He didn't rush it. "We could have kept her stable longer. Maybe not indefinitely... but longer. You said so yourself."

Rowan didn't interrupt.

"She had time," the officer added after a moment. "And we stopped."

"You're not wrong," Rowan said, catching a few of the staff off guard. "We could have extended her condition. But that is not the same as preserving her life."

Another voice stepped in - older this time. Lieutenant JG.

"But it's still time," he said. "Time to reassess. To look for alternatives. We didn't even try."

Rowan nodded slightly, taking the words in. "She was informed," he said. "Of her prognosis. Of our limitations."

"That doesn't mean we stop," the officer replied, not missing a beat. "It means we keep going until there's nothing left."

Rowan let that sit a second longer than necessary. It wasn't defiance he was dealing with here, it was belief.

"We can sustain biological function well beyond the point it resembles recovery," he said at last, not rushing to add the next part. "But that is not treatment."

"It's still a chance though, isn't it?" the Ensign spoke again.

"For who?"

No one answered.

"She made a decision," Rowan continued. "A clear one. With full awareness of what continuing would involve." He paused - not for effect, just... because. "Our responsibility is not to override that because we are uncomfortable with the outcome."

A few of the officers exchanged looks as Rowan studied them. He'd inherited a strong department. Capable. Engaged. In this moment, he wasn't entirely sure if that made this easier, or harder.

"You will no doubt encounter this again," he said. "You will have the ability to extend function. To delay an outcome. That does not mean you should."

He surveyed the gathered group one last time, "You are not required to agree with that," he added. "But you are required to understand it... Before I dismiss you - Counsellors are available if you need them, and my door is open." he gave a small nod, "Return to your stations."

The group dispersed. Rowan picked up his padd and turned toward his office. Footsteps followed him in.

"I still don't agree with you."

He didn't need to look to know who it was.

"I'm aware." Rowan replied, moving in behind his desk and setting the padd down as the Lieutenant stepped in.

"We had time," the officer said. "Not much. But enough to keep trying."

Rowan said nothing, letting the officer continue.

"That's the part I can't reconcile. We're trained to extend life. To look for alternatives when there aren't any obvious ones left. We don't stop just because it's difficult."

"She wasn't a problem to solve," Rowan said, keeping his words measured but firm. "She was a patient. One who understood her condition, her options and she chose not to continue."

"That doesn't mean we stop looking," the officer replied. "It means we work harder. It means we don't decide the limit for them."

Rowan held his gaze. "We didn't."

"That's the problem. We didn't do anything!"

"We recognised the limit," Rowan said. "And we respected it."

The officer studied him for a moment. "That's where we differ." he said, stepping forward. Not aggressive - just certain. "You see that as respect. I see it as stopping short. And I need to understand if that's how you're going to run this department."

"You're questioning my judgement," Rowan said, not looking away. "Not my position."

"That depends," the officer replied, "What I keep coming back to is. " he stopped and started again. "If she hadn't made that call. Would you have kept going?" He didn't wait for an answer. "Because if the answer is no, then this was never just about her. That's your line. And the rest of us are working inside it without anyone asking us."

The silence in the room carried weight. Not uncomfortable. Just.. Present.

"If you believe our responsibility is to override a patient's decision because we are capable of doing more," Rowan said, "then we are not disagreeing about a case anymore.. We're disagreeing about medicine."

The officer held Rowan's gaze for a moment. "I'll continue my duty," he said. "But I don't agree with you."

"I don't require you to." Rowan said simply, inclining his head.

He watched as the officer turned and left. He stood still for a moment, his attention eventually drifting back to the desk terminal though it took a second longer than usual for the data to resolve into anything meaningful.

 

RSS Feed